
案例一,案例二 (1979)
夸克网盘
https://pan.quark.cn/s/6b123b82e339
导演: 阿巴斯·基亚罗斯塔米
编剧: 阿巴斯·基亚罗斯塔米
主演: Ezzatolah Entezami / Masoud Kimiai / Noureddin Zarrinkelk
类型: 纪录片
制片国家/地区: 伊朗
语言: 波斯语
上映日期: 1979(伊朗) / 2004-11-21(希腊)
片长: 48分钟
又名: First Case, Second Case / Case One, Case Two / Ghazieh-e Shekl-e Aval, Ghazieh-e Shekl-e Dou Wom
IMDb: tt0079204
剧情简介
基亚罗斯塔米提出两个案例,让受访者从
道德、权利与责任
的角度进行评判。
案例一:
你的儿子在教室里坐在后排。老师正在黑板上写字,后排一名调皮的学生大声喧哗。老师不知道肇事者是谁,便要求最后两排的所有学生都留在教室外,直到周末,除非有人告诉他是谁在吵闹。在教室外待了几天后,你儿子
妥协了
,告发了那个吵闹的男孩,这样他就能回到教室继续上课。他做得对吗?
案例二:
后排的其他学生则在教室外
坚持等到了周末
,之后才回到教室。他们做得对吗?
Kiarostami presents two cases for talking heads to evaluate in terms of morality, rights and responsibilities. Case One: Your son is in class, sitting in the back row. His teacher is writing on the board. A restless student in the back row makes a lot of noise. Not knowing who the culprit is, the teacher makes all the children sitting in the last two rows stay outside of the class until the weekend, unless they tell him who made the noise. After a few days spent outside of the classroom, your son relents and tattles on the boy who made the noise, so he can go back in and continue learning. Was he in the right? Case Two: The other students from the back row wait out the rest of the week outside of the class, before returning. Were they in the right?
